Major takedown of Boston sports media: Stale reporters, crotchety columnists, and shameless blowhards.

These are cranky times in Boston. The Red Sox were terrible; the Patriots got knocked out; and Rajon Rondo is gone for a long time.

Now add to the mix this piece in Boston Magazine. Writer Alan Siegel basically torches the folks who normally do the torching. Note: This is one of the unflattering photo-illustrations that ran with the piece.

Siegel writes:

To put it bluntly, “The Lodge”—as Fred Toucher, cohost of the 98.5 The Sports Hub morning radio show, mockingly refers to the city’s clubby, self-important media establishment—is clogged with stale reporters, crotchety columnists, and shameless blowhards. Their canned “hot sports takes” have found a home on local television and talk radio, but do little but suck the fun out of a topic that’s supposed to be just that. And we haven’t even gotten to Dan Shaughnessy yet.

I don’t live in Boston and don’t follow the sports coverage on a daily basis. I know many of the writers from sitting next to them in the press boxes through the years. They are some of the best in the business.

However, Siegal’s piece implies the coverage has become lazy. He cites national media beating Boston beat writers on stories on their beats. It also has become predictable.

Siegel writes:

As forward-thinking as that sounds, the newspaper’s core approach to sports coverage—which still relies on boilerplate game recaps, columns, and weekly “notebooks” offering bullet-point takes on the happenings from the various sports leagues—hasn’t changed much over the years. In fact, not much in the Boston sports media has—not even the photos on the wall.

Siegel concludes:

Were the Globe to stop publishing sports tomorrow, how much loss would readers feel? Certainly some, but much less than even a decade ago. That’s because Boston fans have gotten increasingly used to following the ups and downs of their favorite teams in national outlets rather than local ones.

The message to The Lodge is clear: Change, or die the death of utter irrelevance.

Joe Posnanski leaves Sports on Earth for NBC

Joe Posnanski’s wild ride continues.

According to Jason McIntyre of Big Lead, Posnanski is leaving Sports on Earth to join NBC Sports.

From the post:

I spoke with Posnanski Monday by phone as he struggled with the decision to stay or go, and he tells me via text message this morning, “Rough call … yes, going to NBC. Sad to leave, excited about the opportunity.”

Posnanski told McIntyre he will be “a digital voice” for NBC.

Why did Posnanski leave Sports on Earth so quickly? He was the signature hire for the new site founded by USA Today and MLB. For that matter, why did he leave Sports Illustrated? I still think the magazine gave him the best platform to do what he does best: write.

More answers to come, I guess.

Within the last year, Posnanski has left SI; published a controversial book on Joe Paterno; and is on the move again.

Quite a year for a sportswriter.

 

Posted in NBC

Costas to Jon Stewart: There may be something irreconcilable and unreformable about football

I stayed up late last night (at least late for me) when I heard Bob Costas would appear on The Daily Show with Jon Stewart. With the Super Bowl coming up Sunday, I looked forward to what Costas would have to say about football and the game.

However, in the segment that aired on the show, Stewart spent the entire time discussing Costas’ halftime commentary on the gun issue. Even though Costas gave reasoned answers, I’m sure the gun community was incensed. Not that the gun community watches Jon Stewart.

However, I was disappointed since Costas’ gun stance is old territory for me. I wanted to hear him talk about sports. Time, though, ran out, and Stewart said to check the Daily Show site for more of his interview with Costas. Sorry Jon, but I’m going to bed.

I did check the site this morning and saw Costas did give some pointed views about the future of football. At one point, he even mocked the NFL’s health and safety ads, saying, “In the mean time, half of us won’t remember what the day of the week it is by the time we’re 45.”

Even though his network, NBC, has committed billions in right fees to the NFL, Costas is to be commended for going strong on the largest issue facing the sport. Check out what he has to say.

In this clip, Costas recalls the humanity of Stan Musial.

Posted in NFL

Judge Judy over Tiger? Several local CBS affiliates pass on golf tournament

Apparently, not everyone bought into CBS’ decision to air the final holes of the Farmers Insurance Open on the network this afternoon. Despite Tiger Woods romping to victory, several local affiliates passed on golf, opting for their regularly-scheduled programming.

I’m watching golf on CBS2 in Chicago. But other folks aren’t as fortunate.

According to people responding to my tweet, Tiger isn’t on the main CBS channels in Atlanta, Orlando, Providence, Phoenix, Kalamazoo, to name a few.

Some sample tweets:

Albany, NY has it on digital channel. DirecTV does not get the digital channel. Ellen must be popular.

Orlando WKMG CBS 6 passed… Watching on PGA Tour iPad app

Atlanta passed. Bullshit

In some cases, the golf is being shown on the affiliate’s sister or HD channels. However, not everyone gets those channels, as evidenced by the tweeter in Albany. And apparently, there is some confusion. Many people didn’t stick around long enough to get the message to go elsewhere, judging from the tweets.

CBS officials are in full Super Bowl mode in New Orleans and haven’t gotten back to me for a comment.

Obviously, the network is going to hear from plenty of angry golf fans. Then again, if those local affiliates showed golf, they probably would be hearing from angry Ellen and Judge Judy fans.

Next time: Probably best to show entire Monday finale on Golf Channel if a network can’t get clearance from all of its affiliates.

Note: The tournament is being streamed live at CBSSports.com.

 

 

Hockey town Chicago: Blackhawks set another record; peak rating higher than Pro Bowl

Last night, ESPNChicago.com’s Jon Greenberg sent out this tweet:

We need a Blackhawks-Pro Bowl Chicago ratings story tomorrow from @Sherman_Report.

I tweeted back that I thought football, even a lousy Pro Bowl game, still would top hockey in Chicago. Turns out I only was partially right.

The Blackhawks-Detroit game did a 6.31 local rating on Comcast SportsNet Chicago, shattering the regular-season mark set last Tuesday (see below). Meanwhile, the Pro Bowl had a slim edge with a 6.44 rating on WMAQ-Ch. 5.

However–a big however–the Hawks game peaked with a 8.09 local rating (282,000 homes) at the end of the Hawks’ thrilling 2-1 overtime victory. The Pro Bowl, meanwhile, only had a 7.79 peak early in the telecast. Obviously, a few of those bored football viewers in Chicago switched over to the more compelling Hawks game.

All in all, the hockey rating is astounding, considering just a few years ago the Hawks were celebrating if they did a 1.0 rating.

Here are the details from CSN Chicago:

Comcast SportsNet, the television home for the most games and most comprehensive coverage of the 6-0-0 Chicago Blackhawks, delivered its highest Blackhawks regular season rating ever last evening (January 27) — a 6.31 household rating for its live coverage of the Blackhawks home ice battle against the division rival Detroit Red Wings.

For last night’s thrilling 2-1 OT victory by the Blackhawks, Comcast SportsNet attracted approx. 220,000 households for the entire game and posted an 8.09 “peak” rating during the 8:15 PM quarter-hour (approx. 282,000 households).  The 6.31 single game regular season ratings record on Comcast SportsNet shatters the previous record set just five days earlier on January 22 for the Blackhawks home opener vs. St. Louis (5.40).  Source for all ratings information is provided by Nielsen Media Research overnights.

Including last night’s record-breaking rating on Comcast SportsNet, the Top 4 highest-rated Blackhawks regular season games in network history have all occurred over the past six days…note the following:

1)    6.31 –      Blackhawks vs. DET (January 27, 2013)

2)     5.40 –       Blackhawks vs. STL (January 22, 2013)

3)     5.13 –       Blackhawks at DAL (January 24, 2013)

4)     4.39 –       Blackhawks at CBJ (January 26, 2013)

5)     4.35 –       Blackhawks vs. VAN (March 5, 2010)

Comcast SportsNet was also the #1-highest rated television network in the Chicago market last night in the key advertising demos of Men 18-49, Men 25-54 & Adults 35-64 for the entire length of the game (6:00-8:45 PM).  The network was #2 overall in the market in the demo category of Adults 25-54.

Posted in NHL

What is wrong with you? More than 12 million viewers tune into Pro Bowl

Really, don’t you have anything better to do? How about reading a book? Or listen to an audio version of a book? I listened to Tina Fey’s Bossypants during a drive to Indiana University last weekend. Very entertaining.

No, it looks like a significant majority of you tuned into NBC’s coverage of the Pro Bowl last night. According to NBC, the game did a 7.7 overnight rating, which means more than 12 million viewers tuned into the dullest and most worthless sporting event on TV.

To make matters worse, it appears as if the game won the night for NBC. A Sunday night in primetime in January, no less.

That rating will just encourage the NFL and the networks to continue playing this charade of a football game. Dare I say it, maybe they’ll even add a second Pro Bowl, much like baseball did when they used to play two All-Star games.

Speaking of baseball, you can’t be happy that the 7.7 rating for the Pro Bowl was higher than the 7.6 average rating for the four games of the World Series. Perhaps, Joe Buck should do next year’s series with Troy Aikman. Might trick a few football fans into watching.

Yes, we love football. Yes, we do.

 

 

 

Posted in NFL

Q/A with CBS’ producer for Super Bowl: Most football games don’t have Beyonce performing at halftime

Lance Barrow said I helped give him his wake-up call about being the main man for a Super Bowl.

Barrow’s first spin as the coordinating producer for the Super Bowl came in 2007 for the Indianapolis-Chicago game. During a CBS media gathering in Miami, he found himself sitting on a dais with all the network’s heavy hitters such as Jim Nantz, Phil Simms, Dan Marino, James Brown, Boomer Esiason, etc..

“I figure the producer never gets asked anything,” Barrow said. “I’m thinking, ‘How many stone crabs am I going to order tonight?'”

Turns out Barrow was wrong.

“All of sudden, you ask me, ‘How does the Super Bowl compare to doing the Masters?’ Then (somebody else) asks me a question. I came up to you guys later and said, ‘What was that all about?'”

It’s about the Super Bowl, Lance. It’s about being in charge of a broadcast that will feature 62 cameras at the Superdome in New Orleans. It’s about being the man responsible if one of those 62 cameras fails to catch the right angle for a pivotal play.

Not only is the Super Bowl the most viewed event in sports, it also is the most scrutinized. Any mistake, even a blip, gets magnified a thousand-fold.

Barrow is well aware of what he will be walking into Sunday. This will be his third Super Bowl as CBS’ coordinating producer. It will be his 11th overall, dating back to when he was Pat Summerall’s spotter for Super Bowl XII in 1978.

In a Q/A, Barrow talks about the pressure and expectations and how he feels about the reviews as he prepares for the big game Sunday.

You did your first Super Bowl in 1978. What stands out as the major changes in doing the game today.

Obviously, everything is bigger. Not only the game, but everything around the game. You have more equipment, more personnel.  Most football games don’t have Beyonce performing at halftime.

You know it’s the Super Bowl. Nobody has to tell you that.

Is there any extra pressure for you as a producer? You know so many more people are watching and critiquing.

You know you’re doing this huge game that hundreds of millions of people are watching around the world. But it’s a football game. What you’re doing is a football game.

I’m not really about that nervous about it. Sure, there are some nerves. If you didn’t have any, something must be wrong with you.

You don’t want the largeness to overwhelm you. You’ve still got to go out and perform, just like the teams. You don’t want to get too nervous. Otherwise, you won’t be able to perform.

I got into this business to do the biggest events, the most important events that we have at CBS Sports. I’ve been very fortunate that I have been chosen to do these huge events.

I love it. I can’t wait for it. After I did the first one (in 2007), someone said, ‘Aren’t you glad it’s over with? I said, ‘No, I wish we could do it again next week.’

You have so many cameras and gadgets to play with. Do you have to be careful not to overuse them?

You have to be really careful. You have to make sure they don’t get in the way of the broadcast. They are there to enhance the broadcast, not to take away from the broadcast.

Even with 62 cameras, do you ever have any fears of one of the cameras missing a crucial angle on a play?

I expect us to get every angle. My boss (CBS Sports Chairman Sean McManus) expects us to get every angle. We expect that every week. We expect everyone to perform at a top level. We’re the No. 1 crew at CBS Sports. We’ve been given this opportunity to produce the Super Bowl.

I don’t go into the game worrying if we’re going to have the right replay. I expect it to happen.

During the 2010 Super Bowl, New Orleans coach Sean Payton opened the second half with an onside kick. It caught Indianapolis by surprise. Did it catch you by surprise? Explain what went into covering that play.

Nobody told us they were about to do an onside kick. Sean Payton had mentioned to us in our meeting, ‘Bill Parcels said you’ve got to lay it on the line for a big game.’ Payton said, ‘Don’t be shocked if I do an onside kick.’ It could have been the first kick of the game or the last. Nobody is calling us and saying, ‘Hey, by the way, get ready, we’re going to do an onside kick.’

We were as surprised as Indianapolis was. But (director) Mike Arnold had the Skycam on, and this is where teamwork comes into play and being prepared for that moment. I always think about the great line in the movie, Tin Cup (in which Barrow, Nantz and other CBS staffers had roles). Kevin Coster says, ‘You could define the moment, or the moment defines you.’

CBS Sports defined that moment. We had the Skycam on. Instead of going away to follow the kick (like a sideline camera), the Skycam followed the ball. When it came time, we had the right replays. Then you start thinking about not only who covered it, but did it go 10 yards?

You have 40-50 replay devices. You’ve got to make sure you pick the four or five replays that show the right one. That’s what we did.

Do you worry about the reviews? Do you read them?

I don’t worry about too much about them. Sure, I’m interested in what they have to say. It’s human nature. You want to be liked. But at the same time, I only can produce the game and do the coverage the way we think we should do it.

It’s live television. It’s not a perfect science. I have in my mind what (legendary golf producer and Barrow’s mentor) Frank Chirkinian said once in an interview: ‘If I ever produce a perfect show or game, I will turn around and walk away from this business because I never will be able to accomplish it again.’

It took me a few years to realize that. He’s right. I said to our crew before the the AFC title game: ‘Tom Brady or Joe Flacco might throw an interception, but that doesn’t mean they won’t wind up with five touchdowns.’ It’s the same thing with us. It’s 3 1/2 hours. It’s beyond split-second decisions that are being made. You hope you make the right moves.

When it comes to the Super Bowl, I always joke that I’ll be on a plane at 6 on Monday morning, going off to Pebble Beach (to produce CBS’ coverage of  the AT&T National Pro-Am). By Monday afternoon, I’ll have a golf meeting. Less than 24 hours after you’ve done a Super Bowl, you’re on to something else. That’s the way it is.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Tiger effect, No. 1,862: CBS to air finish of today’s golf tournament

The normal procedure is to push coverage to the Golf Channel when regular a PGA Tour event spills over to a Monday. And if it was Brandt Snedeker or Nick Watney holding a commanding lead today, CBS would say, “It’s all yours, Golf Channel.”

So why is CBS airing the final holes of the Farmers Insurance Open Monday afternoon? Two words: Tiger Woods.

Woods carries a six-shot over Snedeker and Whatney with 11 holes left to play. CBS wants to show Woods either marching in for the victory or folding down the stretch, which still is a possibility with the new-age Tiger. Either way, the network wasn’t about to miss a chance to air Woods in the hunt during the final round of a tournament.

As a result, the Golf Channel will handle the earlier holes today, beginning at 2 p.m. ET. Then it will hand off coverage to CBS at 4 p.m. The Tiger Show will give the network a nice lead-in to the evening news.

From the San Diego Union-Tribune:

“CBS wanted to put it on and wanted to finish at 2:30 p.m. local time,” said Mark Russell, PGA Tour tournament director. “They’re our partner, so we went with it.”

Asked if he knew if the network’s decision was based on Woods, Russell took a mulligan.

“I have no idea,” he said. “I’m not a network executive in New York. “They’re our partner and they wanted to show it and we accommodated them.”

No need to ask, Mark. It’s all about Tiger.

Note: If you’re out or stuck at work, the coverage will be streamed live at CBSSports.com and via its mobile app.

 

 

 

Costas at the Movies: Penny Marshall says Demi Moore literally got ‘screwed’ out of lead role in ‘A League of Their Own’

Next on Costas at the Movies: Penny Marshall and Geena Davis discuss A League of Their Own (Monday, 8 p.m. ET, MLB Network). As always, Marshall is very entertaining.

Highlights from MLB Network:

Penny Marshall on Demi Moore almost being cast as Dottie Hinson:

“Demi Moore, I liked, but by the time we came around, she was pregnant. So Bruce [Willis] literally screwed her out of the part.”

Marshall on hiring Madonna:

“I lost a girl who was good because her pilot went for television, so that takes first priority. So I had to look for a hot girl who could dance. … Well, [Madonna] could dance and she’s hot. So, she was on her way to Cannes for ‘Truth or Dare’ to promote that and I said, ‘Well, I can’t wait.’ So she tried out in New York at St. John’s. …  In three hours, the coaches called [and] said, ‘Trainable.’”

Marshall on casting Tom Hanks:

“Tom Hanks came to me and wanted to be in it because he had had some movies that didn’t do so hot.”

Marshall on actresses playing hurt:

“They all played injured. Lori [Petty] had a cast on. Rosie [O’Donnell] had broken fingers…They played their hearts out because they respected these ladies.”

Geena Davis on learning to play baseball:

“Before the movie, I couldn’t play baseball at all…But I got pretty good.”

Davis on who the best player in the cast was:

“Rosie O’Donnell, no doubt. She could actually play.”

Davis on portraying the quirks of a baseball player:

“I made a bit of a study of that kind of thing. I watched a lot of baseball and tried to pick up people’s mannerisms.”

Davis on wearing skirts to play baseball:

“Some of our real cast, from sliding into home, had ripped the skin off their legs. It was nutty.”

Posted in MLB

Winning PR game: Colin Kaepernick sent pizzas to 49ers media trailer

The 49ers QB is really smart. Writes Scott Ostler in the San Francisco Chronicle:

The 49ers‘ media trailer at  the team complex in Santa Clara has been jam-packed with hard-working reporters.  Thursday afternoon a delivery person arrived with 15 large pizzas, compliments  of Colin Kaepernick.

A thoughtful gesture? More like astounding.

Not that the media can be bought off with pizza, but … OK, we can.